What the CHI Spinal Scandal Reveals About Patient Safety
The CHI Spinal Scandal has become one of the most disturbing cases of medical negligence in Ireland in recent history. It involves the alleged use of non-medical grade ‘spring’ devices during complex spinal surgeries on children at Children’s Health Ireland (CHI) in Temple Street. These implants were not CE-approved, meaning they did not meet required European safety standards.
For many families, this scandal is more than a news story, it’s a devastating personal crisis. As investigations unfold, the scandal raises serious questions about patient safety, hospital oversight, and the legal rights of those affected by medical negligence in Ireland.
External link: Read the original story in The Times
Understanding Medical Negligence in Ireland
Medical negligence occurs when a healthcare provider fails to meet the expected standard of care, resulting in harm or injury to a patient. In Ireland, victims of medical negligence have the right to seek compensation through legal channels.
In the case of the CHI Spinal Scandal, affected children may have experienced:
- Unnecessary surgical procedures
- Exposure to non-compliant medical devices
- Delayed or mismanaged post-operative care
- Lack of informed consent from parents or guardians
Each of these failures may form the basis of a valid medical negligence claim in Ireland.
How Could This Happen?
The Health Service Executive (HSE) has launched an internal investigation, and an external clinical review is underway. However, reports suggest that concerns about the surgeon’s practices were raised as far back as 2019. Despite this, no immediate action was taken.
The scandal points to a systemic breakdown in hospital governance, including failures in:
Monitoring device approval and usage
Medical oversight
Safety auditing
Reporting and responding to whistleblowers
Your Rights as a Patient in Ireland
If you or your child were treated at CHI and you’re concerned about your care, you may have legal rights to:
- Access full medical records
- Request an independent medical review
- File a formal complaint with the HSE
- Pursue a medical negligence claim for injury or trauma
In Ireland, you generally have two years from the date of discovery of the negligence to bring a legal claim, though exceptions may apply in the case of children.
What Should You Do Now?
If you suspect your child was impacted by the CHI Spinal Scandal, or you’ve experienced poor care in any Irish hospital, you should:
- Request your full medical records from CHI or the HSE.
- Contact a solicitor with experience in medical negligence in Ireland.
- Avoid signing any hospital/NHS correspondence without legal advice.
- Begin documenting your child’s symptoms and outcomes post-surgery.
At Sweeney Solicitors, we specialise in handling complex medical negligence claims and are currently assisting families affected by the CHI Spinal Scandal.
How Can We Help?
We offer:
- Free initial consultation
- Full medical file reviews
- Access to independent medical experts
- Trusted legal representation
Do You Think You or Your Child Were Affected?
The CHI Spinal Scandal is not just a one-off case it’s a wake-up call for transparency, accountability, and reform within Irish healthcare. But most importantly, it’s a moment to stand up for patients’ rights.
If you or your child were affected by medical treatment in CHI or any other hospital, don’t delay. Legal advice can make all the difference.
If your child had spinal surgery at CHI or you suspect any form of medical negligence get in touch for a free consultation. You may have a valid claim, even if the incident occurred several years ago.
📞 Call us on 1800 246 442
💻 Or book a confidential callback at info@sweeneysolicitors.ie or david@sweeneysolicitors.ie